(Editor's Note: This is an outstanding piece written to speak to a
set of corporate core values. However, they can be easily applied to other sets of 'core
values' (for instance, Civil Air Patrol's are: Integrity, Volunteer Service, Excellence,
Respect) with just a little mental gymnastics on the part of the reader.In
addition to being an excellent analysis from a leadership and teamwork perspective, this
piece is also a good example of how things we come across every day - in this case a TV
program - can be used to create a lesson in a way that anyone can understand.
CadetStuff.org would like to thank the author for reprint permission.)
Love or hate 'reality-TV' shows such as Survivor, they can often provide an
opportunity to learn from the behavior of others. Combat Missions, Mark Burnett's latest
creation for USA Network is no exception - and a recent episode provided a reminder of how
important it is to know what your values are when life puts you in an 'ethically
challenging' situation.
The show brings together military and law enforcement personnel into four teams to
compete in mock missions based on real life combat situations. Winners keep their teams
intact, the losers are forced to discharge a team member and pick someone new. In this
particular episode the mission laid before two of the teams was to rescue a TV anchorwoman
being held hostage inside a low-rise apartment building by a group of armed gang members.
Everyone involved with the competition wears special equipment, known as MILES (Multiple
Integrated Laser Engagement System) gear, to make the missions something like a game
of laser tag. If a team member, bad guy, hostage or bystander is hit, a tone sounds and
that person is considered dead insofar as the game is concerned. Of course, a critical
element to the mission at hand was to protect the hostage and avoid harming any
bystanders.
While both teams laid out a similar strategy to accomplish their mission, Alpha team,
considered the underdog to undefeated Bravo team, became preoccupied with keeping the
hostage alive. So much so, that when their team leader suggested they cover up the MILES
gear to keep a "hit" from registering, only one team member objected. Quickly,
it was decided that they would use a poncho to protect the victim from 'shock.' Although
they knew they were breaking the rules, the fact that the suggestion came from their team
leader seemed to make it a legitimate strategy, rather than an attempt to cheat.
The opposing team, Bravo, completed their mission with 925 points out of a possible
1000 - an excellent score. Thanks to excellent teamwork and preparation, Alpha Team
finished with 955 points, and clearly had the unexpected win. Unfortunately for them,
their deception did not go unnoticed. In clear violation of the rules, they were docked
250 points - the same penalty they would have received if they had failed to protect the
hostage. Alpha Team not only lost the competition, they also lost the respect of the other
teams, the referees and the audience.
How would having well-defined values, like those at BCNEPA, and living by them have
allowed Alpha Team to avoid this lose, lose situation? Clearly, if they had brought Integrity
to the planning process, the idea of covering up the detection equipment would have been
quickly discarded. The team member who did object might have received more attention, and
might have spoken up more forcefully, had there been Respect for differing
opinions. Team members also needed to Trust that their Team Leader would not set
out a strategy that was unethical. Finally, having a Commitment to the spirit of
the competition, rather than a 'win at all costs' attitude would have created an
environment in which a decision to cheat had no place.
When you're in a situation where cheating seems easy, stop for a moment and consider your
values.